Las Vegas Democratic debate live updates: Six candidates face off in Nevada

Fact check: Did Klobuchar vote to make English the national language?

Buttigieg laid into Klobuchar for supporting legislation to declare English the official langue of the U.S.

“Do you know the message that sends in as multilingual a state as Nevada, to immigrants?” he said.

Klobuchar was one of 17 Democrats to support a 2007 amendment ending a requirement for federal agencies to provide materials in languages other than English, according to The Associated Press. She disavowed this stance last week, saying English shouldn’t be the national language of the U.S.

‘No Social Security or Medicare cuts’ if Bloomberg elected, top adviser says

LAS VEGAS — Mike Bloomberg would oppose any cuts to Social Security or Medicare if elected president, his senior campaign adviser Howard Wolfson said here Wednesday after the debate.

Wolfson said those retirement programs would be off the table in a Bloomberg presidency, marking a shift from the former New York mayor’s past positions in support of reducing benefits to lower the deficit.

“We’re at a point where working people in particular are feeling squeezed about the future, where you have dislocation and job loss, you have entire industries that are contracting,” Wolfson told NBC News. “And now is not the time to be putting those kinds of things on the table in context of deficit reduction. Mike has a plan to raise taxes to pay for a lot of the investments we need. But no — no Social Security or Medicare cuts.”

Fact check: Did Klobuchar support the most Trump judges?

Buttigieg claimed that Klobuchar was most likely to vote for Trump judges “of the senators running for president,” earning a complaint from the Minnesota senator that his numbers were wrong.

“I have opposed, not supported, two-thirds of the Trump judges, so get your numbers right, and I am in the top 10 to 15 of opposing them,” Klobuchar said. 

But Buttigieg didn’t say she’d voted for Trump’s judges two-thirds of the time. He said she’d voted for Trump’s judges more than any other Democrat on the stage. And that’s true.

Here’s the fine print of what everyone’s talking about: progressive blog ThinkProgress reported nearly a year ago that Klobuchar had voted for more than 56 percent of Trump’s judicial nominees who were eventually confirmed — that may be where Klobuchar prepped her two-thirds number response. 

Her campaign told NBC News on Wednesday night that those numbers are outdated and that using that same methodology, the senator has voted in favor of Trump’s judicial nominees just 33.51 percent of the time. That’s still more than Sanders and Warren, who voted for Trump’s judicial nominees about 25 percent of the time by the same math.

The ninth Democratic debate, by the numbers

This was an … active debate. The six candidates onstage took swings at one another and at President Donald Trump but mostly at new-to-the-debate-stage candidate Mike Bloomberg, who was targeted 45 of the 95 times candidates attacked one another. According to NBC News analysis, the 95 attacks mark the most times candidates have attacked one another in any of the Democratic debates.

For full numbers on candidate attacks, read our Las Vegas debate candidate attack tracker.

The debate ended with Sens. Elizabeth Warren and Amy Klobuchar topping speaking time with 16 minutes each, edging out the initial front-runner, Sen. Bernie Sanders.

Read our article about candidate talking time in the ninth debate.

One more number of note: Sanders’ 13 attacks on Bloomberg, the most of any candidate in the debate.

Who won the Democratic debate in Las Vegas?

Bloomberg became a piñata, and Warren resurrected her feisty side.

The Democratic candidates formed a circular firing squad Wednesday night, with arrows flying in all directions and fights breaking out among a seemingly infinite permutation of candidates on matters from health care policy to lewd comments about women.

The debate was not only the former New York mayor’s first time on a presidential debate stage; it was also the first night of his surging campaign that wasn’t choreographed. The result: He faced direct criticism from rivals he has bested in recent polls. It was the most contentious evening of the nine faceoffs so far, coming three days before the Democratic candidates face the most diverse voting electorate yet in their quest to make Donald Trump a one-term president.

“It’s a little bit like a presidential version of ‘Survivor,'” former Sen. Claire McCaskill, D-Mo., said on MSNBC after the debate.

Here’s a look at who was the most aggressive, who took the toughest punches and who missed their marks over the course of the debate, which was hosted by NBC News, MSNBC, Telemundo and The Nevada Independent.

McCaskill: Las Vegas debate was ‘a presidential version of “Survivor”‘

Warren says she had her best fundraising day ever

Warren says Bloomberg will spend money to ‘erase America’s memory’ of the debate

Speaking with MSNBC after the debate ended, Warren said Bloomberg will spend a bunch more money in the coming days “in order to try to erase America’s memory of what happened on that debate stage.”

Warren brought what many considered to be the strongest performance of the night, highlighted by her repeated tough exchanges with Bloomberg, who was making his first debate appearance.

After the debate, Bloomberg campaign manager Kevin Sheekey said in a statement: “You know you are a winner when you are drawing attacks from all the candidates.”

“Everyone came to destroy Mike tonight. It didn’t happen,” he said, adding, “He was just warming up tonight.”